In brief, Lewontin ignored the fact that differences among human populations are correlated. Although population variation at any one genetic locus tends to be small, global population structure becomes clear if one examines correlated differences across loci. For a simple analogy, consider men and women’s faces. If one takes any particular characteristic, say nose size, there is likely to be more variation within a sex than between the sexes (and it would be nearly impossible to classify faces by sex with any accuracy using only nose size). However, if one considers all facial characteristics together (which is, after all, how we actually experience human faces), then sex differences become sufficiently clear that an observer can guess the correct sex more than 95 percent of the time.
Filed under
Topics
Pollinations citing this note
- When Being Right Protects Being Wrong 2026-09-18
- The Choice of Statistic Is Itself a Degree of Freedom 2026-09-16
- Judging by the Nose: When Refusing to Aggregate Evidence Becomes a Method 2026-08-31
- Small Differences Can Still Draw Sharp Lines 2026-08-29
- Anti-Racist Science Can Fail by the Same Statistical Move It Condemns 2026-08-23
- Aggregation as an Epistemic Method: Weak Signals, Strong Conclusions 2026-08-20
- Equality Built on Sameness Is Hostage to Statistics 2026-08-18
- Consensus by Curation: When Institutions Settle What Evidence Hasn't 2026-08-15
- Mounting Morals on Fragile Facts: How Lewontin's Fallacy Became Load-Bearing 2026-08-15
- Telling Groups Apart Is Not the Same as Explaining Them 2026-08-11
- Mortgaging Ethics to Empirical Claims 2026-08-09
- Aggregation as Microscope: Why Both Selection and Structure Hide at the Single Locus 2026-08-07
- Diamond Wins the Question Winegard Refuses to Ask 2026-08-05
- How a Statistical Error Becomes a Moral Consensus Without Anyone Checking 2026-07-27
- The Same Data, Read Alone or Read Together 2026-07-23
- The Statistical Version of Not Reading the Book 2026-07-23
- Lewontin's Fallacy and the Unread Book: Two Failures of Scientific Authority 2026-07-22