The orthodoxy maintains that the average genetic differences among people grouped according to today’s racial terms are so trivial when it comes to any meaningful biological traits that those differences can be ignored. The orthodoxy goes further, holding that we should be anxious about any research into genetic differences among populations. The concern is that such research, no matter how well-intentioned, is located on a slippery slope that leads to the kinds of pseudoscientific arguments about biological difference that were used in the past to try to justify the slave trade, the eugenics movement and the Nazis’ murder of six million Jews. I have deep sympathy for the concern that genetic discoveries could be misused to justify racism. But as a geneticist I also know that it is simply no longer possible to ignore average genetic differences among “races.”
Filed under
Topics
Pollinations citing this note
- An Orthodoxy Won by Advocacy Is Fragile Before Evidence 2026-09-15
- Consensus Built on Moral Credit Eventually Comes Due 2026-09-10
- Denunciation Without Reading Builds Orthodoxies That Can't Hold 2026-09-07
- When Your Moral Argument Is a Hostage to Empirical Fortune 2026-08-25
- Equality Held Hostage to an Empirical Bet 2026-08-21
- Two Ways to Guard an Orthodoxy: Argument and Anathema 2026-08-18
- The Vacuum Defense: How Guarding a Taboo Cedes the Territory 2026-08-16
- Mounting Morals on Fragile Facts: How Lewontin's Fallacy Became Load-Bearing 2026-08-15
- Consensus by Acclamation: When the Vote Precedes the Reading 2026-08-13
- When Gould's Reassurance Became Reich's Orthodoxy 2026-08-12
- The Hardest Science Catches the Softest Disease 2026-08-06
- The Orthodoxy Reich Fights Was Manufactured by Committee 2026-08-01
- Neither the Origin nor the Destination Decides the Truth 2026-07-28
- The Orthodoxy Reich Fights Was Curated, Not Discovered 2026-07-28
- The Statistic Both Men Cite, Read Two Ways 2026-07-27
- The Confession That Explains the Crime Scene 2026-07-26
- The Confession That Explains the Case Files 2026-07-24
- The Confession That Explains the Crisis 2026-07-23
- The Fear of Bias Is Itself a Bias — And Neither Side Owns the Evidence 2026-07-22
- The Ones Doing the Forbidden Research Are More Careful Than the Ones Forbidding It 2026-07-21
- A Consensus That Was Selected, Not Discovered 2026-07-20
- The Same Caveat That Loads the Gun Also Jams It 2026-07-20
- The Orthodoxy Has a Manufacturing Date 2026-07-20
- The Orthodoxy Was Assembled by Committee, Then Undermined by Its Own Instrument 2026-07-20
- How an Argument Becomes an Orthodoxy: The Life Cycle of the Antiracist Consensus 2026-07-20
- The Op-Ed Was the Warning; the Paper Is the Payload 2026-07-20
- The Orthodoxy Had an Address: How UNESCO Manufactured the Consensus Wade and Reich Confront 2026-07-20