A more plausible conception of race, one that is consistent with how careful philosophers and geneticists use the term, recognises that: When humans began leaving Africa around 75,000 years ago, they dispersed across a much greater range of environments than they had previously inhabited. The humans that settled in different geographic regions subsequently came under different selection pressures (e.g. temperature, seasonality, altitude). Natural barriers such as oceans (e.g. the Atlantic), deserts (e.g. the Sahara) and mountain ranges (e.g. the Himalayas) impeded gene flow between different populations for substantial periods of time. When there is limited gene flow between populations that have come under different selection pressures, we would expect them to gradually diverge from one another over via the processes of genetic drift and natural selection.
Filed under
Topics
Pollinations citing this note
- Geography Is Not an Alternative to Genetics—It's the Mechanism 2026-09-17
- When Both Statistics Are True, Authority Decides — and Shouldn't 2026-09-16
- Race Science as the Stress Test for McIntyre's Checklist 2026-09-06
- Both Sides Can Be Reading the Genome Correctly 2026-09-04
- The Bet on Barriers: Divergence Was Geography's Accident, Not Nature's Verdict 2026-08-30
- When Scientific Consensus Is a Show of Hands 2026-08-30
- The Verdict Arrives Before the Evidence Is Read 2026-08-28
- When Your Moral Argument Is a Hostage to Empirical Fortune 2026-08-25
- When the Verdict Precedes the Evidence: Lewontin's Non Sequitur and the AAA's Empty Hands 2026-08-24
- History Is Not an Alternative to Biology 2026-08-23
- History Is Not the Opposite of Biology 2026-08-16
- The Vacuum Defense: How Guarding a Taboo Cedes the Territory 2026-08-16
- The Regress of Bias Detection 2026-08-11
- When the Empirical Claim Ends and the Verdict Begins 2026-08-11
- Consensus as Campaign: When Scientific Authority Is Spent Rather Than Earned 2026-08-08
- The Whole Debate Reduces to One Empirical Question: Did Evolution Stop? 2026-08-02
- The Same Geography, Opposite Verdicts on Biology 2026-07-25
- Gould's Timescale Assumption Meets the Data 2026-07-23
- Geography Is Not the Alternative to Biology—It's the Mechanism That Produces It 2026-07-22
- Lewontin's Fallacy and the Unread Book: Two Failures of Scientific Authority 2026-07-22
- The Empirical Paper Confirms the Premise but Muddies the Picture 2026-07-21